FutureCopLGF's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Pico Untamed]

Hrmm, got a bit of a mixed impression on this one. In general I like what this game was going for and thought it had a lot of cool ideas and some nice touches, but many parts of it just felt unfinished or confused, giving a bad impression.

As said, I think it does a decent job at attempting to be a Pico's School style game. The story is an interesting exploration of the themes of Pico with all the various choices to make, the presentation and animations are very nice, the point n click adventure is decent with all the necessary elements of exploration and inventory management in place, the boss battles have a great variety of interesting patterns, and I love some of the little flavorful touches like boyfriend getting scared if you fire off some shots around him: you didn't have to add that but you did and it adds so much life and humor to the world!

But while all the ingredients are there in theory, so much of it felt really badly executed:

*The adventure felt a bit too linear, scripted, and easy for my tastes: would've loved a greater sense of exploration and problem solving, but the game world is just too tiny that it ends up leading you straight to solutions without even having to engage your brain. All of the little minigames like hiding and sneak attacking the guard felt so token and handholdy instead of being an interesting system to engage with: would've loved if the guards were more like Nemesis stalking you and you need to randomly react to their appearances in time.

*While some people might defend it, I didn't like how the game didn't highlight interactables when you hover over them (besides the obvious arrows) which made it confusing to determine what you can click on.

*The boss battles felt so terrible: without any sort of blood splatters or reactions from Pico and the boss when taking damage, without any sort of telegraph from the bosses for when they make an attack, without clear hitboxes for explosions and attacks, without any sort of strategic limitation to fire rate or ammo and being able to just spam-click until your ears blow out from the repetitive noise, it all just comes together feeling like a confusing, lifeless, dull mess.

And so on and so forth. Definitely feels like this had a great design and passion that could've came out great, but might not have had enough time to fully solidify the execution, leaving it ultimately feeling unfinished and lackluster. While that is a bummer, I think the hearts in the right place, I didn't completely hate my time with it, and it shows a great deal of potential: would love a more polished version of this or at the very least, would love to see future games from you!

TrickWithATwist responds:

First off I just want to say thank you so much for playing the game and leaving a detailed and thoughtful review. I'm sorry that your experience was mixed and you have brought up a lot of valid points. I really wish I could have properly fleshed the game out and make it more dynamic but due to tight time constraints and attending university a lot had to be scrapped. I really appreciate your feedback and I'll definitely keep this in mind once I work on future projects. :)

[Package Man]

Hrmm, not much to say unfortunately. Once you've played the game for a few seconds, you've seen pretty much all it has to offer, and while you can derive some minor pleasure from running around and throwing boxes and watching them bounce around, I didn't feel like the delivery mechanics were exciting enough to make me compelled to go for a high score, especially since the whole scoring system is comprised by random box variations that can give you an unfair lucky advantage (two people could play just as skillfully as one another, but one could have a lucky run where they get some +1 boxes).

I think the concept does have some merit: trying to deliver packages rapidly by having to both plot a course through a complex environment and manage precise/risky manuevers like throws could certainly be fun. The execution to me at the moment feels rather halfbaked and insubstantial: maybe if it had more interesting levels/geometry to get through (maybe even changing the terrain every delivery so you need to constantly react and replot your path), some fun risk/reward mechanics (like maybe being able to damage the box with bad throws), and altogether just had a bit more pizazz, it could be nice! As it is, though, I'm not seeing a great hook to make it a memorable experience.

CaperCube responds:

I think most of your points are right on and are things I'd much like to address if / when I come back to this project.

Watching your video review, I noticed that you picked up on this being an Ludum Dare game. tbh, we 100% could have done a better job with this project, but we missed most of the jam an only had 8 hours to put this thing together. I was surprised when we got FP'ed here, but I'm glad a bunch of people were able to have fun with it!

Thanks again for playing and reviewing!

[Pizza Dash]

Was pleasantly surprised with this one!

While it had a very slick and stylish presentation to it, I gotta admit that I didn't have the greatest initial impression with the gameplay mechanics: the movement that makes you feel like you're constantly slipping on ice and the very slow and awkward grappling mechanics were incredibly unwieldly to get used to and I was certain that I would quit from frustration shortly.

But surprisingly, I felt like I had a great time with this game! Yes, the controls are a bit awkward to get used to and I feel like better setups could've been made (like maybe allowing you to cancel a grapping shot midway so you don't have to awkwardly commit to a miss), but everything seemed to come together with a little practice and I got in a great flow state, so clearly the levels were designed to work with the mechanics very well.

My only real complaint with the game was that I wish it had more as it ends just as it is getting good! It did a great job at introducing new interesting mechanics like the grapple and pizza, and it gave a great example of some of the more complex challenges it could build up to, with the whole last gauntlet where you need to launch the pizza to lower the electricity and then make it through in time to collect the pizza and exit. Would love to see a more finalized version of this, or perhaps just another great action/precision platformer from you in future!

[Mya's Pizza]

A bit mixed on this one! I'm a huge fan of this job simulation/management games and this one looked really promising on initial inspection: presentation was very charming, game feels well constructed, tutorial taught everything quite effectively, and the feel of answering calls and sending out the drivers and all that was nice. Definitely feels like there was a lot of polish, which is impressive for a game jam game!

I gotta admit, though, that after playing it for a bit, I was disappointed with the gameplay mechanics and the lack of any complexity or evolution to them. The act of answering phones, sending out drivers, and handling in-store orders was dead simple and the game never introduced any other mechanics beyond that: the only thing it did was increase the volume of orders to deal with, which could be challenging, but since you're upgrading your cooks and drivers in tandem with that, there's functionally no appreciable difference as the days went on.

The whole allure of these games for me is the engaging improvisational plate-spinning and rapid-fire decision making you have to do, and while I don't necessarily think this needs to be like Papa's Pizzeria or Cook Serve Delicious where you physically get your hands in the dough while also managing the store, it really felt like there needed to be something more to this as it just keeps looping the same stuff from the first day. Maybe if more obstacles came up that you need to contend with as the days went on, it'd keep things engaging, like maybe having to draw a path for your drivers to avoid traffic jams that pop up, or maybe having to memorize and relay customer's desired ingredients to the cooks, or so on. We don't even seem to get bonus cash for getting an order done quickly: that could've added some incentive. Unfortunately, it felt like a real style over substance situation: would love to see an enhanced version with more complexity to it however as it did have a good initial impression.

Also, as a side note, there are some non-functional aspects to the game like the pause button not doing anything (luckily you can just unfocus the game and that pauses it).

[Witch's Familiar]

It's a decent concept that shows some good promise, but at the moment it feels a bit underwhelming due to a lack of content/progression and the presence of bugs.

I enjoyed the basic premise of picking up and dropping objects, but it really didn't evolve in any significant way to keep my interest: many of the levels do the same pattern of 'drop package on switch to get rock to put on switch instead of package' and it was only the very last level that finally changed things up with a few interesting tricks before it was over and left me feeling unsatisfied. Would've loved if there were more mechanics to deal with or really brainy puzzles that took advantage of the premise more: as it is, it's ok, but quite boring and doesn't feel unique or memorable.

The game was also quite buggy, with the major bug being that the objects like packages and rocks don't have their rotations locked, meaning that they can actually tip over if you place on the edges of platforms. This can create very glitchy behavior where, if you pick up a rotated rock and then drop it, you can end up blasting away from each other, most likely because your hitboxes are intersecting upon drop off since it isn't giving enough clearance between the two (since it expects the objects to be flat rectangles in their original positions) and the physics engine tries to rectify it by moving them away from each other. There are other minor bugs like how the 'z to drop' message doesn't disappear if you place a cog in a switch, and the animation of the bird freezes if you walk on the ground.

It's understandable since it was made in such a short time frame, I suppose, and like I said I did have a decent time and it does show promise if it was further developed, but I wanted to give my opinion on it lacking as a full game since, after all, this has been submitted on newgrounds, not the game jam site, so I think the context is fair. Would love to see an enhanced version with more meat on its bones!

nion-ne responds:

Thanks for the coverage and the lengthy feedback, especially impressive after playing so many games. I mainly kept the rotating and janky physics because it was funny in a kind of half life 2 sort of way, but definitely agree that a polished version would need to be predictable.

More mechanics would be nice. A struggle during the jam was thinking of mechanics that wouldn't be too contrived or difficult to implement reliably in the short time available. For instance a "draw string" that powers machines for a short time while pulled. But ultimately I decided on being short, simple, and easy so that most ludum dare players would be able to complete it.

A more complete version is something I'd love to do after my current project. There's a number of ideas I'd love to implement, both narrative and mechanical.

As for submitting to Newgrounds, it's mainly because they were advertising for the game jam, that being said these are all points I will take into account if I take this project further.
Thanks again :)

[Boxbrawl Delivery]

Wow, I loved the hell out of this game! Feels like a fantastic combination of great polish/presentation with a solid execution on a unique gameplay concept, and while it does use a retro look to add appeal, I found it legitimately charming and well-done, not some sort of nostalgia bait to garner points. The strategy the game promotes is cool: it was a real pleasure to chuck boxes at enemies and catching the rebounding box all in a smooth motion, and I loved racking up a huge load of stunned enemies before turning in the package for a big bonus. Game also has so many little touches to it that add so much flavor: the animations for your partner in the truck, the speech bubble responses from customers based on the box's condition, the ending point tally which spins the time down and depletes the stars one-by-one, the way the time flashes red to let you know that it went down from your damage, all-around really wonderful stuff that I'm quite impressed got done considering it was a game jam!

That said, while I did overall love my time with it, I did have some feedback for improvement:

*I loved chucking the box at enemies and catching the rebounding box, but it was very frustrating that it only worked if you were spaced a good distance: if I tried to chuck a box close-range at an enemy, the box would just fall to the floor and ruin my flow. This was especially annoying when dealing with snails who you want to chuck it twice at rapidly but can't if the box just falls to the floor when you should catch it for that second needed toss! Speaking of tosses, there were also some weird occasions where the tossed box would both hit an enemy and the floor at the same time, acquiring some unfair damage that should've been cancelled from the hit.

*The whole "damage depletes your time" mechanic was a bit annoying and I'd prefer a different solution: too many times I'd take damage and get time so low that I was in a 'dead man walking' state where I didn't have enough time to beat the level without dying no matter how hard I try so why bother? Do I keep trying despite having no chance or just hurt myself to bring it to zero? Very awkward.

*The game kind of peters out as it stops introducing new enemies and just recycles the same levels over and over with more packages to be delivered and larger enemy density. I wasn't sure if it had an ending to strive for or if it was just looping and it made me feel like it was a bit pointless. I know retro games like Mario Bros and Wrecking Crew and all that do just loop like this, but I'd love a bit more of a sense of progression and finality: as it stands, the game just plays until you get bored with it, which kind of sours the last impression you get.

*Difficulty is a bit wonky: snails are super difficult to deal with and they appear quite early on, while frogs are much simpler and appear after snails, creating an awkward spike. Feels like they should've been reordered in appearance. Enemy density can get so high and the flies which hurt you for stalling can feel unfair when compared to it since you might practically have no choice.

[The Hunt]

Initial impressions of the game weren't that great. While it does have a rather eye-catching and stylish presentation to it with its black-and-red palette reminiscent of a Virtual Boy game, I found the gameplay mechanics to be very bog-standard and clunky with all sorts of weird and buggy physics (like if you jump while running into a wall, your jump will be cut short for some reason, and you can get caught on edge pixels which awkwardly stop your jump where other games would smooth them out). Furthermore, the levels were tedious as well with tons of boring backtracking through already cleared areas to collect another blood mark all the way on the other side of a level (why not just have a blood mark teleport you back to the center instead of having to walk back, or maybe make new enemies pop up to make the trip back interesting?)

So overall, I found myself getting quite bored and feeling like the game was something like a student's first project: commendable for a first start but nothing great for public consumption. I will give the game credit, however, that it did seem to do a pretty good job with level design: every new level seemed to introduce some new crazy layout filled with unique geometry, obstacles, traps, enemies and objectives. I also did like some of the small touches made to the game, like the way enemies explode with gibs (though the gibs did also glitch out in weird ways here and there, like spawning in a different spot than where the enemy was). Certainly some good effort and potential on display: if the game just had a bit polishing and more interesting mechanics, I think it could be pretty decent!

[XOXO Puzzle]

Not too shabby! It's a little simple and barebones, so I was really surprised by how very addicted I got to this game, though that's all due to the bonus par score challenges pushing me to understand the optimal techniques better, and how it kept things fresh by mixing things up with new rules for placement of symbols, which were very intuitive to understand thanks to the great asterisk that previews your move. A nice short and sweet puzzler with a good amount of cleverly designed content!

[Dashmo]

Hmmm, this one's a bit of an odd duck! I really want to like it and I do think it is pretty cool for the most part, what with its crazy frenetic energy and unique strange yet appealing style, but I did have a lot of annoyances with it as well that brought down the experience considerably.

When the game is working, it delivers some great fast-paced fun like a Warioware minigame gone bananas. Keeping track of your character and making lightning quick decisions to deal with all the sudden obstacles can get you in this crazy trance, propelled by the eclectic visual style and crazy music. Or at least, it should get you in a trance state, but...

But overall, playing the game felt like constantly stubbing my toe, where I kept running into issue after issue that impacted my fun and made it just feel too confusing and unfair.

The placement of collisions/hitboxes felt very awkward, especially due to the tilted perspective: so many times I'd think I hit something but didn't and vice versa, like I'd think I'm standing right in the path of the bullet but actually I'm a little in front of it.

Adding to this was the difficulty in seeing where the character's shadow was: it was so faded and barely visible, especially when contrasting against the dark ground and so many other visual flairs competing for attention like the reflection that I could never tell where my exact position was.

Controls just felt really inconsistent and wild at times: sometimes I could dash over a red pit and other times I'd take damage, sometimes my character would be difficult to turn or ignore my inputs in random ways before going back to normal, and so on.

The game just felt super unfair at times, sometimes spawning you into a room where you take immediate damage from a rotating pit spinning unavoidably quickly, or perhaps spawning you into a room and you can't even tell where you are until you realize you're right under the floating chaser enemy blocking your vision or you just generally get lost in the sea of overly loud and garish graphics and can't pick yourself out.

I could go on, but basically, it might be a game that's a bit style-over-substance: a good concept for a game that delivers some decent fun but is a bit too overly-stylized that it hurts readability and brings it down.