FutureCopLGF's game Reviews on Newgrounds

[Slim Wall Reslimed]

Auuugh, this was a really rough one for me! I want to love it so bad, but I came away feeling frustrated.

When the game works, it absolutely nails it: the smooth feeling of speed and momentum that you get from dashing in and out of the blocks is sublime, and the game delivers so much great challenging content to go through! This game gave me the need, the need for speed!

But goddamn, the game really felt unpolished: when it wasn't bugging out and glitching me into areas I shouldn't be in and just being wonky with collision detection, it was constantly dropping my inputs leading to tons of unfair deaths. The game desperately needs to iron out the jank: first and foremost I would suggest some sort of coyote time mechanics to allow for easier edge jumps and last-second jumping out of blocks, because even when I tried to get used to this game's unforgiving input buffering and hit my inputs earlier than I traditionally would, it would still drop them tons of times.

Please, please, if you can, release a more polished version of this game! The core mechanics here are fantastic and deserving of more work than the two weeks challenge can offer.

Oh, and I also liked the tunes.

[Temple of Kashteki]

Wow, really great little adventure here! Gives me Celeste vibes from the similar type of bubble mechanics and the professionally-made graphics, animation, and game feel (well, I did feel like the size of the orb hitboxes were a bit too small, but otherwise everything felt pretty smooth). Just moving the character around by itself was a delight, and once you add everything else, it was awesome. Definitely had a blast playing this: it started out a bit slow, but eventually really ramped up the challenge with some hard layouts and then ended it with a great boss/chase setpiece. My only real complaint is that I wish there was even more to it, as I felt it ended before the challenge could peak and get really crazy and creative, haha!

I did have a weird bug where my movement would freeze for a second at random times? But I think it was something on my end: seemed to resolve itself once I unplugged my controller? Since, maybe worth investigating to see if something weird is going on there. But otherwise, it's all good.

SECURAS responds:

Thanks and also thanks for making the video. The feedback is most appreciated. I apologize for the movement bug but I really could not replicate it. Unfortunately, browser games sometimes are more or less friendly depending on the browser so that may explain it. I really only tested using chrome. I would have liked to make more but I really had no time. This was made for a game jam and I only had a week to make it. So I just did the basics and, as usual in game jam games that are to be played for less than 10min, I made it very accessible.

I did enjoy that you quickly picked up on my "fake challenge" rooms that look like a complicated challenge but actually run almost automatically. Not everyone gets it so its clear you have an eye for level design. I needed to place these rooms to give confidence to the player. Then, when the real challenges come along, the player will have an extra boost of confidence. I also had zero effort rooms right after harder rooms for a similar effect... To calm down the player and avoid a death right after beating a challenge. You never want to kill someone's streak.

[Newgrounds Intern DEMO]

Definitely an interesting little platformer! I love the cool 3D title screen where it zooms around to the various options, and I thought the gameplay was pretty decent, finding these various quests and going exploring here and there. Liked some of the inclusions like a helpful checkpoint button that spawns a box in the warehouse to make it easier to recover after a fall, and how you put money on the warehouse lamps to let people know you could jump on them.

However, at the end of the day, the game felt incredibly bland. Now some of this could be explained because its a demo, such as the lack of satisfying visual/audio effects for picking up money: perhaps that's going to be added later. But I'd argue that something as core and repeated to a platformer as collecting should be made satisfying post-haste, and I was sad to see how muted it was in this game. The worlds were also really unexciting with you jumping through boring warehouses or sewers: definitely could use some more colorful terrain and more interesting obstacles (it did feature some fun moving platforms in the sewers, but too little too late for me). Finally, the game really didn't have any interesting movement mechanics: just a stock-standard run and jump. They say that you can tell a platformer is going to be fun if you can have fun just running and jumping around a practically blank room: it's certainly something I was able to do in games like Super Mario 64 where I could spend hours just running around the courtyard, not even playing a real level, but in this game? No dice.

I also did have a frustrating bug where the camera would sometimes snap several degrees to another direction without my input: sometimes this would happen mid-jump and cause me to fall to an incredibly unfair death.

Hoping that this game can continue to get worked on: with some more juice to the important interactions like collecting, more exciting worlds and obstacles and a more interesting movement/jumping physics system, it could be a neat little Newgrounds platformer!

[Kolo Terorita]

Hmm, had some decent fun with this, but really felt mixed on it.

On one hand, the game does have a subtle but rather effective addictive nature to it where your armament keeps increasing bit-by-bit to thwart the ever increasing enemy horde: very Risk of Rain of Vampire Survivors type stuff. I was impressed to see that new enemy types were being added over time, and I was also impressed that enemies actually had damage/stun states with animations for them. And of course, the game does have a certain charm to it with its wacky presentation and comical game over messages like "the shakeover is shake over". Definitely gives it a certain Newgrounds-esque vibe, particularly with the meme references.

But on the other hand, the game really does come off as a lazy babys-first-top-down-shooter game. Overall the game just feels incredibly bland, dry and lifeless due to the lack of animation (especially for movement) and visual/audio effects (especially for feedback), along with the very boring world and repetitive gameplay with enemies that can mostly be easily thwarted by circling around constantly. And as said before, while the game can be somewhat addictive due to the pattern of increasing armament, it doesn't have anything original to add and easily just makes you want to play a better version of this type of gameplay.

With a bit more polish to the core gameplay to make it feel more exciting and satisfying to match the amusing charm and wackiness that the game already has, I feel like it could be a pretty fun shooter, but for now, it just feels very amateurish (but if you're just starting out, I'd say that it's a good first attempt).

[GansWare]

A pretty lacking, but nice prototype for a Warioware-esque game. It definitely does have some issues, the most obvious being the lack of unique minigames (it starts repeating them so quickly, sometimes the same one over and over) and the lack of any sort of increasing difficulty/speed as the game goes on, leading to boredom quickly. Some of the games also seemed quite wonky, like how the art juggling one ends so fast with a single juggle instead of requiring you to juggle until time ran out (I'd mostly win without me needing to move at all, in fact). Finally, I found it weird that none of the games were goose-themed despite the game seeming to be themed around geese (yes, the arms are there in the intermissions, but c'mon, that's pretty shallow). However, at the end of the day, it's impressive for a weekend jam and I could easily see it being built upon to be a great game. I also liked how nice the title screen was considering it is a jam game: some fully-released games don't even have nicely animated title/buttons as this, surprisingly!

[Defend 'Till the End]

Solid arcade fun! It's a simple game to pick up and understand and it feels quite satisfying to blast asteroids away thanks to the juicy effects. It's also quite exciting to see your options and weapons build-up bit-by-bit. Was also really impressed at some of the effects such as how when an asteroid hits the planet, it models a crater on the earth at the exact point of impact: so cool to see that as it spins around, it's like Doom Eternal level of visible damage feedback. It's not the longest lasting game as it does start to get a little repetitive, but it's a solid and fun score-attack while it lasts.

Only major issues I had was that I feel like the ammo counter shouldn't be overlayed on top of the weapons: it just turns it into a graphical mess that is hard to parse (for example, it made it difficult to see how many bullets were being used for each weapon). And speaking of that, it was difficult to figure out the weapon system in the first place and keep track of unlocks since the pop-ups for them come and go so quickly. Oh, and I did have some confusion when the game would auto-switch back to the machine gun when I run out of missile ammo: I always expected to have to switch back manually so the automatic nature actually caught me off-guard.

KJScott responds:

Yeah, totally agree with the ammo counter (I wasn't happy with it myself). I tried multiple iterations and at the time I hadn't figured out a good way of resolving that as of yet. If I do an update I'll focus on that to try and fix that. Maybe a new ammo bar and fixed max ammo cap might help?

I messed about with the message speed and how long they last. I found adding an extra second or so obstructed view too much and I did have a feeling that the current level was too short. Again, if I update I will have another look at that. The main reason why it's too quick is that due to the ongoing "research" I would have had to added extra code to handle multiple messages at the same time. Looks like if I update I'll need to address this issue.

With the auto-switching back to the machine gun, I found during playtesting by myself if you had to manually switch back by the time you realise it's not firing you have pretty much lost the game as the half a second to second to realise and make the switch meant you were dead. So unsure about changing that.

[Newgrounds Burger Quest]

You know, for as low-effort and goofy as the game looks, there's actually a decent little adventure in here. I liked wandering around and picking up clues from the various denizens to figure out how to get all 5 dollars for whatever a Newgrounds burger is. I also liked all the little touches that the game had, such as the cool shooting animation (and ending animation, speaking of), the ability to blast everyone, the hidden fishing minigame, and of course the funny dialogue and sounds. So unlike how it looks, there is some intentional design and effort put into it here and there, and it is quite charming in that respect.

But at the end of the day, it definitely was a pretty janky and short game. Now some of the jank could be excused by it being true to the design and goofy aesthetic, but some of the annoyances like the vague hitboxes, delayed shooting animation, random spawns and so on could just be plain frustrating, leading to unfair deaths.

And I gotta say that you did commit a game design cardinal sin in my book. If you design a dialogue system with text that gets typed out, a player should always be able to hit a button to have the text immediately fill to the end (and not skip to the next line until another press). This game does not allow that, and for that, you will burn in heck for you have damned so many players to waste so many seconds waiting for the text to fill out: so many seconds!

plufmot responds:

Thanks! Also you can press and hold Z or M to speed up dialogue!

[Pee Man vs the Monkeys]

Well, putting aside the initial pee-remise and all of its strangeness, this game had some really solid, simple, fun arcade action! Love the whole retro arcade graphics, love how it gets to the action quickly, love the juicy (maybe bad word choice?) effects, love the exciting yet janky music that matches the tone, love the strategy of having to aim your shots as to not waste your pee and gather resources to get pee back, and love the secret hard mode! Certainly had a good time playing this game for most part: was surprised at some aspects like how short damage-invincibility lasts, but everything was mostly intuitively designed. Game can be a bit confusing at times where I couldn't tell whether levels ended when some invisible timer was over or when the enemies were killed (most likely both have a factor). I also got screwed over once when it froze projectiles on a level transition which caused me to run into it (I expected them to keep going). Would love if the game had a little bit more to it, but it had enough for a short and sweet adventure.

[NG STARS]

Hmmm, this one is a bit rough for me and unfortunately a case of style over substance in my opinion.

On initial impression, I think that the game is very cool and impressive. The game definitely has a professionally-constructed feel to it, what with the very animated and lively menus, title screen, and seems to have a lot to offer with its huge character roster. And indeed, I did have some good fun going through and seeing how each of the characters played and catching references and such: I could easily see some people having fun going through and building a tier list and other such things.

But at the end of the day, once the novelty of checking out the roster is gone, all you are left with is a game that is a shallow as a puddle. I found the characters to be terribly unbalanced, the combat to be overly simple and unsatisfying, and there were no unique systems or level terrain or strategy or any sort of hook to work with. Now, I'm not saying it needs to be some super complicated fighter with guard-breaks and astral finishers or whatever: games like Divekick and Footsies and Fantasy Strike are excellent games with very limited movesets. But those games, unlike this, have an actual deep system and strategy to their seemingly simple combat that acts as a hook. Or, if a complex system is not the way to go, at least the game should have some sort of wacky party elements like a Smash Bros or Mario Party game that shake things up.

The menus were also confusing and complicated at times: for example, had no idea why the game wants me to have to right-click to disable a character choice instead of just letting me left-click on a new character no problem, and why does it not automatically assume that 1P has already joined and instead make me have to join manually every time? And let's not even mention that it doesn't even teach you how to play (as funny as whatever the heck that video was...)

I definitely do love the idea behind this game and think a NG artist brawler could be great. If this was just to serve as a proof of concept for an upcoming version which has more content, online play, actual fighting systems, and so on and so forth, I would absolutely love that!

So far I feel like Peti might be the best fighter?

Stepford responds:

Fair enough! This game was more of a love letter to our friends in the community than anything else. Just a bit of fun! <3

[SHRIMP-OS]

Wow, blown away at the level of content, charm, and sheer polish in this bad boy! So much to do and so much to see: after quite a long while, I thought I had found a goodly-sized portion of what's on offer only to see so many achievements left unlocked still! Definitely had a good time not only searching through this Hypnospace-esque scavenger hunt and seeing so many funny things, but also had a blast checking out the various apps and the games as well! The games, jeez, they'd be enough for a submission itself, but to see these games within games, I seriously need to give props to the developers to have the guts to have these really intricate games be hidden within another game where they might not even possibly be found (but I certainly hope most people do find them)! Goddamn, I absolutely loved the new Bimsy, that by itself deserves 5 stars and I find it crazy that it's not available standalone!

So for the most part, I had a great goofy experience with this and plan to revisit it to see what else I can find. I definitely love it a lot. But, if I had to nitpick some stuff in here, well, here are some nitpicky things:

There were some occasions where apps would be a bit of a let-down or their functionality would be odd. For example, I found the paint app really pathetically simple and was disappointed it had barely any features and no save/print option (and if I were to re-open a picture I was working on, it would corrupt the colors). The music listener was really difficult to manipulate the timeline slider: it's like you'd have to click at an odd spot and sometimes it wouldn't accept where I'd place it. I could go on, but I feel silly saying all this as it's all very minor stuff that never really broke or bothered me: for the most part I was impressed with the apps. Again, it's all very understandable and fine for some slight jank since there's just so much in this OS, but it's just a bit unbalanced where some apps, like the music maker, are so great, while others really don't add much. Take it as a compliment that this game really raised my expectations that I kept expecting so much greatness.

Unfortunately I found the Ugby Mumba game to be really not my taste. It's a shame, but to me, it's a bit of a style over substance thing: I really, really want to like the game based on how smooth and juicy and professionally looking the game is, clearly there was a lot of effort and love there, but at the end of the day, the gameplay itself just seemed very repetitive and boring and I could barely bring myself to finish 2 levels. Bit of a shame since the game seems to put such importance on it to not only make it fullscreen, but to not even let you quit out of it without resetting the entire OS!

There were some other minor kinks like the help pop-ups not staying long enough/waiting for confirmation before leaving or having some where you could reference them once again if you forgot the tip. I also didn't like how the game couldn't find a solution to scrolling except to keep badgering you to hold a button when you scroll: surely there could've been a more elegant way to solve this as I know I've played games before they accept scrolling without scrolling the web page as well? You can't blame the user for expecting something as simple as this to be in place.

At the end of the day, cheers for this great piece of work: definitely a very impressive collab!